Accident Legal vs Richardson & Lyons compared on fees, specialists and offices (2026)
On our October 2026 scoring of Accident Legal vs Richardson & Lyons, Accident Legal scores 61/100 (31st in Queensland) and Richardson & Lyons scores 56/100 (42nd). Neither has a QLS Accredited Specialist on our check, and both have offices in Greater Brisbane and Gold Coast. Scores count public records, not case results.
Written and fact-checked by Marshall Fenech, Editor. Firm facts checked 20 October 2026. How we rank firms.
At a glance
|
Accident Legal31st in Queensland |
61/100 |
|---|---|
|
Richardson & Lyons42nd in Queensland |
56/100 |
|
Both in |
Greater Brisbane and Gold Coast |
Facts checked 20 Oct 2026.
Accident Legal vs Richardson & Lyons side by side
Every fact below comes live from each firm’s checked profile. Swap either firm, or add a third, with the lists.
Accident Legal vs Richardson & Lyons, side by side
| Fact | Accident Legal | Richardson & Lyons |
|---|---|---|
| Score (out of 100) | 61/100 | 56/100 |
| Best for | Firm founded by former insurer-side lawyers, with eleven listed offices including Noosaville and Rockhampton | Injured workers who may also need employment advice. The firm acts for injured people and, separately, for employees in workplace disputes. |
| Has a QLS Accredited Specialist | Not published | Not published |
| Published fee terms | States it works on a no win, no fee basis ('If we don't get you compensation, you don't pay us anything') and…States it works on a no win, no fee basis ('If we don't get you compensation, you don't pay us anything') and the first consultation is free. Describes a 'No Disbursement Loan Promise': the firm fronts every cost, charges zero interest and recoups only when the insurer pays. No published fee cap or uplift statement found. | Handles all injury damages claims on a 'No Win – No Fee' basis and says 'We pay all of the outlays required fo…Handles all injury damages claims on a 'No Win – No Fee' basis and says 'We pay all of the outlays required for your claim – even if your case is unsuccessful.' Fees are charged at rates based on lawyer seniority rather than as a percentage of the payout, subject to Queensland's 50/50 rule. The firm says it does not charge out of a WorkCover Notice of Assessment lump sum if no common law claim is pursued. Free, obligation-free initial consultations (including by phone or Teams). It notes the risk of paying the other party's costs if a claim fails. |
| Doyle's Guide | Recommended 2026 | Recommended 2026 |
| Google rating | 4.8 (61) | 4.9 (37) |
| Queensland offices | Brisbane CBD +10 offices | Brisbane City +3 offices |
| Claim types | 6 of 8 Car accident (CTP), Medical negligence, Motorcycle accident, Public liability, TPD & superannuation, Workers compensation | 6 of 8 Car accident (CTP), Dust diseases, Motorcycle accident, Public liability, TPD & superannuation, Workers compensation |
| Firm type | Independent Queensland firm | Independent Queensland firm |
| Founded | Not published | 1991 |
| Facts checked | 20 October 2026 | 20 October 2026 |
Facts come from each firm’s profile, with sources and check dates. How scores work.
Key differences between Accident Legal and Richardson & Lyons
Which firm suits which need
No firm suits everyone. For each common need, this shows which of the two firms meets it, from checked public records:
|
If you want |
Consider |
Why |
|---|---|---|
|
A QLS Accredited Specialist in Personal Injuries Law |
Neither. Compare other firms |
Checked on the QLS register |
|
A Doyle’s Guide 2025 or 2026 listing |
Both firms |
Doyle’s Queensland plaintiff lists |
|
Fee terms you can read before you call |
Both firms |
Published on the firm’s website |
|
More Queensland offices to meet in |
11 offices against 4 |
|
|
Medical negligence claims |
Listed by Accident Legal only |
|
|
Dust diseases claims |
Listed by Richardson & Lyons only |
About Accident Legal
Accident Legal is a Brisbane-based personal injury and compensation firm. Accident Legal Pty Ltd (ABN 50 603 012 568) operates the firm. See the full Accident Legal profile.
About Richardson & Lyons
Richardson & Lyons is a Brisbane-based law firm. It acts in personal injury claims and, separately, for employees in employment disputes. See the full Richardson & Lyons profile.
How we compared them
Both firms are scored out of 100 on the same public records: a QLS Accredited Specialist (25 points), Doyle’s Guide listings (up to 20), Google rating (up to 20), fee terms published on the firm’s website (15), claim types (up to 10) and Queensland offices (up to 10). Neither firm paid to appear, and we take no referral fees. Read the full method.
Frequently asked questions
